The one constant in life is that, at some point, everyone must die. Of course, this is not exactly encouraging news but the rationalization of this concept has led to some very interesting beliefs and creative manifestations. In order to explain why we die, the notion of fate inevitably evolved. The myth goes that every mortal’s destiny was transposed as a string by the Moirae. At the moment of birth, a human’s “thread of life” was spun by Klotho and measured by Lakhesis. In the Greek world, nothing was set in stone and fate could be altered by choice, coercion of the Moirae, or direct intervention of the Olympian gods. When the experiences of a mortal’s life led to an end, the thread was cut by the most feared of the Moirae, Atropos (Moirae). The fates of cities and the progression of the world in general are not associated with strings, but are determined by the combined fates of the citizens. Fate plays a tremendous role in the Iliad and by looking at various other themes derived from ancient Greek morals, their heroes, gods and the interactions between them, we shall see how difficult it was for the Greeks to fulfill the inevitable destruction of Troy.
The Olympian gods, although unable to die, were still subject to the fate of the world in which they lived. Every god had his or her favorite city or person – perhaps more than one of each – and would take it personally when something (or someone) disrupted their “plans.” Sometimes conflict broke out between two or more gods over unexpected intervention, but mostly, the gods tried to remain on good terms. In the Iliad, the idea that the gods could affect the fates of mortals and cities is addressed. Zeus, as the upholder of justice and order, oversees the predetermined fate of Troy. Despite King Priam, and for that matter, Troy itself, being on Zeus’ A-list, Troy must be razed.
Why this conflict even started has to do with the first Greek moral on the list: xenia. Xenia used to be a most sacred tradition, and the consequence of forsaking this moral is what started the Trojan War. When Priam’s son, Paris, violated xenia by eloping with the wife of the king of Sparta, Menelaus, he not only damned his family’s kleos – immortality in the memory of others through the acquisition of timé – but triggered all of Achaea to unite for war and invoked the wrath of fate (Bulfinch). With fate turned against Paris’ family and, subsequently, Troy, the stage is set for the end of the House of Priam. The Greeks lived by a different set of rules than we do today and defying those rules had dire consequences.
Next we address the all-important concept of a hero’s honor and why such allies as Achilles and Agamemnon turned against each other. From line one of the Iliad, Homer tells us that fate has decided how it will end. “Rage—Goddess, sing the rage of Peleus’ son Achilles, murderous, doomed, that cost the Achaeans countless losses…, and the will of Zeus was moving toward its end. Begin, Muse, when the two first broke and clashed, Agamemnon lord of men and brilliant Achilles” (Iliad, 1.1-8). It is difficult to say what Achilles’ fateful choices would have been had Agamemnon, king of Mycenae and brother to Menelaus, not taken as geras Chryseis, thus bringing Apollo’s plague. Upon resentfully returning her home and taking a loss on his own personal timé, Agamemnon demands Achilles’ geras. Achilles’ rage flares and he moves to kill his ally and commanding officer not knowing it was against fate. The immediate intervention of Pallas Athena stops Achilles from killing Agamemnon and destroying his true purpose (Iliad, 1.232-261). Only with Achilles’ cooperation can Agamemnon bring down the city of Troy, retrieve his brother’s wife, and right the violation of xenia.
A crucial characteristic that begins to develop in Achilles—against social norm—is that geras is temporary while kleos is essentially eternal. Achilles relents the geras Agamemnon wants, but backs out of the war and threatens to go home (Iliad, 1.394-405). A roundabout prayer to Zeus ensures that Agamemnon will suffer for his selfish actions (Iliad, 1.484-411). Hera is furious. “…I suspect you bowed your head in assent…you granted once and for all to exalt Achilles now and slaughter hordes of Achaeans pinned against their ships” (Iliad, 1.670-672). According to prophecy, Troy is supposed to be taken after ten years of war. If Achilles were to leave—or if Hera’s suspicions are true—Agamemnon’s remaining troops would not be able to sack the city and, being pinned down, they would ultimately lose the war. Achilles would live a long, peaceful, yet unremarkable, life without contributing to his family’s kleos. Fate teaches us that no human life or fabrication is eternal. However, actions speak stronger than, well, burnt bones in the ground. Honor from glory in battle is one of the most immortalizing aspects of ancient Greek life, hence why Achilles remains. When the Achaeans are backed up against their ships, Agamemnon realizes he needs Achilles’ help and offers him a multitude of geras to rejoin the battle with more timé than before, to which Achilles says, “…What do I need with honor such as that? I say my honor lies in the great decree of Zeus” (Iliad, 9.740-741). By this point, Achilles is aware of his choices and is on the verge of alienating himself from the Achaeans and the traditions he has known his whole life. But because of his quest for kleos, geras is no longer important to him.
Anthropomorphism, or the attribution of human characteristics to inorganic things, is a large part of Greek belief and is applicable not only to natural phenomena such as weather, spirits in trees and rivers, but even the armor a soldier wears. A hero’s armor represents much more than just protection and, in the case of Achilles’ extraordinary armor, turns out to be the catalyst which sparks the tragic end of the Iliad (Shmoop Editorial Team). When the Trojans advance far enough to burn one of the Achaean ships, Patroclus dons Achilles’ famous armor which scares Hector’s troops enough to scatter. In fact, the effect of Patroclus’ genius plan is that the Trojans are pushed back to the Scaean Gate. But this is where fate kicks into overdrive. Zeus pushes Achilles’ dearest friend into battle with Hector, a fight that only Hector—aided by Apollo—walks away from with Achilles’ armor as well as a fresh boost to his ego (Iliad, 16.914-1012). If we consider that the armor Hector has stolen has an allegiance to Achilles, Hector should certainly be afraid of the ultimate consequence of wearing it.
As it turns out, Hector’s fate is to wear the incompatible armor in his confrontation with Achilles, who wears his new, fancier armor made by Hephaestus. Hector faces Achilles one-on-one to prove to his city, and overwhelming ego, that he is Troy’s hero. The word kleos ringing in his head, he willingly martyrs himself. “The rest of [Hector’s] flesh seemed all encased in armor, burnished, brazen—Achilles’ armor that Hector stripped from strong Patroclus when he killed him—true, but one spot lay exposed…” (Iliad, 22.379-382). And so Achilles assumes his fate and ensures the eventual sacking of Troy by avenging his dear friend.
Compassion, mourning and, ultimately, forgiveness form the most emotional and unexpected twist to a war story, but every story needs something startling before the end. The honor code dictates that a killed Achaean should be avenged and a proper burial ceremony was required for a soul’s passage to Hades. Achilles violates this right for the house of Priam and takes out his pain from losing Patroclus on Hector’s dead body (Iliad, 22.466-476). But despite Achilles’ rage, the gods push him beyond his rebellious and grieving persona by making him realize that he needs to forgive Hector and release the body to Priam. Only by accepting his situation can both sides grieve their losses and let the inevitable war continue. For now, fate calls for the walls of Troy to crumble.
The fates of Hector, Troy, and Achilles have fascinated listeners and readers for almost 3000 years, but there will always be new conjectures about it. Though it may seem odd that Homer lets Achilles and Hector know their fates, as an oral tradition it can be easily reasoned out. The original audiences would have known the story well. By incorporating a deeper level of understanding of the characters, the audience (and eventually readers) become much more absorbed into the conflicts they are involved in. Predetermined fate may or may not be a real part of life, but it certainly is real in our imaginations. And for some people, that is enough to believe that they are destined for something specific and strive to do good, or perhaps bad, things. If an ancient tradition such as the Iliad can inspire imagination, creativity, and benevolent aspirations, perhaps fate is more real than we might think.
Bibliography
Bulfinch, Thomas. The Myths of Greece and Rome. NY: Penguin Books, 1981. Print.
Garrison, Patricia. “How Achilles and Hector Respond to Similar Situations.” Patricia Garrison’s Web Pages. Central Washington University, 2013. Web. 18 Sep. 2013. http://www.cwu.edu/~garrisop/sample_midterm_papers.pdf
Homer. The Iliad. Trans. Robert Fagles. NY: Penguin Books, 1990. Print.
Jordan, Herbert. “Chance, Gods, and Fate.” The Iliad of Homer. University of Oklahoma Press, 2008. Web. 18 Sep. 2013. http://www.iliadtranslation.com/fate.html
Leonard, Scott and Michael McClure. Myth and Knowing. NY: McGraw-Hill, 2004. Print.
“Moirae.” Theoi Greek Mythology: Exploring Mythology in Classical Literature & Art. Amazon, 2011. Web. 18 Sep. 2013. http://www.theoi.com/Daimon/Moirai.html
Morris, Ian and Barry B. Powell. The Greeks: History, Culture, and Society. 2nd ed. Boston, 2010. Print.
Powell, Barry B. Classical Myth. 7th ed. Boston: Pearson, 2012. Print.
Shmoop Editorial Team. “The Iliad Themes” Shmoop.com. Shmoop University, Inc., 11 Nov. 2008. Web. 18 Sep. 2013.
Sienkewicz, Tom. “The Gods in The Iliad.” Department of Classics. Monmouth College, 2003. Web. 18 Sep. 2013. http://department.monm.edu/classics/courses/clas210/coursedocuments/epic/godsintheiliad.htm
“Themes, Motifs & Symbols.” SparkNotes. B&N, 2013. Web. 18 Sep. 2013. http://www.sparknotes.com/lit/iliad/themes.html